Acting · Chicago, Illinois, USA · Born April 16, 1977
MacArthur completed his high school studies at Deerfield Academy. After this, he joined Bowdoin College to pursue a Bachelor’s in Government. To pursue his interest in acting, he later enrolled in Groundlings Theater Company and Atlantic Theater Company, too. He made his feature film debut with Homo Erectus, portraying Thudnik. However, he is most widely known for playing Jay Geils in Angie Tribeca. His other acting credits also include Go On, Worst Week, A Haunted House 2, Being Frank, and others. He also made guest appearances in popular shows like How I Met Your Mother and Happy Endings. —via yahoo movies
MovieA Love Like This
2026
as Paul
TVThe Runarounds
2025
as Finn Cooper
MovieDear Santa
2024
as Bill Turner
TVHistory of the World: Part II
2023
as Mark
MovieThe Binge
2020
MovieThe Way Back
2020
as Eric (uncredited)
TVMerry Happy Whatever
2019
as Sean Quinn
TVThe Morning Show
2019
as Marlon Tate
TVMr. Mom
2019
as Greg Anderson
MovieBeing Frank
2019
as Stan
MovieI'm Just F*cking with You
2019
as Chester
TVSingle Parents
2018
as Xander Fogerty
MovieSuper Troopers 2
2018
as Mountie Podien
MovieDirector's Cut
2016
as Reed
TVAngie Tribeca
2016
as Jay Geils
TVReally
2014
as Charlie
MovieA Haunted House 2
2014
as Ned
TVFriends with Better Lives
2014
as Zac
TVLate Night with Seth Meyers
2014
as Self - Guest
MovieSomeone Marry Barry
2014
as Rafe
TVThe Rebels
2014
as Rick Massella
TVLooking
2014
as Barry Foster
MovieThe Motel Life
2013
as Officer Cook
MoviePrep & Landing: Totally Tinsel Collection
2012
as Thrasher (voice)
TVGo On
2012
as Wyatt
MovieThe Babymakers
2012
as Leslie Jenkins
MovieJewtopia
2012
as Chuck O'Connell
TVKey & Peele
2012
as Jack
MovieBachelorette
2012
as Dale Beaumont
MoviePrep & Landing: Naughty vs. Nice
2011
as Thrasher (voice)
TVSuburgatory
2011
as Walter
TVWhitney
2011
as Lance
TVHappy Endings
2011
as Steven
TVPerfect Couples
2010
as Rex
MovieLife As We Know It
2010
as Peter Novak
MovieShe's Out of My League
2010
as Ron
MoviePrep & Landing
2009
as Thrasher (voice)
MovieLower Learning
2008
as Digdug O'Shaughnessy
MovieLook
2007
as Tony Gilbert
TVPushing Daisies
2007
as Buddy Amicus
MovieThe Game Plan
2007
as Kyle Cooper
MovieHomo Erectus
2007
as Thudnik
MovieAre We Done Yet?
2007
as Jimmy the Bartender
MovieThe Adventures of Big Handsome Guy and His Little Friend
2005
as Guy Hansen
TVHow I Met Your Mother
2005
as Curt
TVMedium
2005
as Randy Pilgrim
TVEntourage
2004
as Levinson
TVCurb Your Enthusiasm
2000
as Doorman
TVThe King of Queens
1998
as Ed
